Reference

SPIN question bank for advisory discovery

Part of the Proposal Sow Writing skill · loaded on demand from SKILL.md

Read this when preparing a discovery, scoping or re-scoping meeting. The bank is organised by SPIN stage (Rackham, 1988) and, within each stage, by the function of the person across the table, because a CFO and a head of operations feel the same problem in different units. Pick five to eight questions per meeting; do not read the list. Every question is written to be asked aloud.

Two rules from the research. Ask few Situation questions: the client finds them tedious and they expose a lack of preparation. Ask more Implication and Need-payoff questions than feels comfortable: these are the ones most associated with success in large sales and the ones sellers most often skip.

Contents

  1. Situation questions
  2. Problem questions
  3. Implication questions
  4. Need-payoff questions
  5. Questions for the advance
  6. Re-scoping questions for a live engagement
  7. Sequencing patterns

1. Situation questions

Ask only what you cannot find in public filings, the website, prior decks or the RFP. Phrase them to show what you already know.

General

  • "I have read the last two annual reports and the board paper you sent. What has changed since the board paper was written?"
  • "Who owns this problem today, and who else thinks they own it?"
  • "What has been tried in the last two years, and what happened to it?"
  • "How does a decision like this get made here: who has to agree, and who can stop it?"
  • "Is there a date this has to be resolved by, and what sets that date?"

CEO or business-unit head

  • "Which of your priorities for the year is this getting in the way of?"
  • "When the board last discussed this, what was the question they asked that you could not answer?"

CFO

  • "How is this visible in the numbers today: which line, which report, which frequency?"
  • "What is in the current plan for this, and is the plan believed?"

Head of operations or sales

  • "Walk me through how the decision is made at the front line today. Who decides, within what limits?"
  • "Which two or three sites or teams would you point me to as the best and the worst at this?"

Head of a function (HR, IT, procurement)

  • "What does your function get asked for on this that it cannot deliver?"

2. Problem questions

Surface difficulties, dissatisfactions and gaps. Ask about areas your engagement can address.

General

  • "Where does the plan miss most often, and by how much?"
  • "What takes longer than it should?"
  • "What do you find yourself explaining to the board every quarter?"
  • "If you could see one number you cannot see today, what would it be?"
  • "What decision have you been putting off because you do not trust the data?"

CEO

  • "Where are your leadership team not aligned on this, and what is the disagreement actually about?"
  • "What are you being told by people who benefit from the status quo?"

CFO

  • "Where do you suspect margin is leaking but cannot prove it?"
  • "Which forecasts are you least confident in?"
  • "What does the investor or lender ask about that you would rather not be asked?"

Head of operations or sales

  • "What rule or policy do your people work around most often, and why?"
  • "Where do you lose customers or output that you think you should not?"
  • "What do your best people do that your average people do not?"

Middle managers and front line (interviews during scoping)

  • "What is the most frustrating part of this process for you?"
  • "When you have to make an exception, what is usually the reason?"

3. Implication questions

Take each problem and explore its consequences: cost, spread, duration, what it prevents. These questions grow the client's perception of the problem until it outweighs the fee. Do the arithmetic with the client, out loud, and write down their number.

Cost and size

  • "What does that cost you in a year, roughly? Let us do the arithmetic together."
  • "If that leakage is 1 percent of revenue, is that 4 million? Does that sound right to you, or high, or low?"
  • "How much of the gap to plan does this explain on its own?"

Spread

  • "Who else feels this? Sales, finance, the sites, customers?"
  • "What does it do to the people whose bonus depends on this number?"
  • "Does it show up in customer behaviour: churn, complaints, share of wallet?"

Duration and trend

  • "Has this been getting better or worse, and what is driving the trend?"
  • "If nothing changes, where is this in twelve months? In twenty-four?"
  • "What has to happen for it to fix itself, and how likely is that?"

What it prevents

  • "What is this stopping you from doing: investment, hiring, a deal, a price move?"
  • "What conversation with the board or the investor does this make harder?"
  • "What would you do with the money if you had it back?"

Decision risk

  • "If you make the decision the board is pushing for without this data, what could go wrong?"
  • "What is the cost of being wrong about this, compared with the cost of being late?"

4. Need-payoff questions

Have the client describe the value of solving the problem, in their words, and rehearse the case they will make internally. These are the questions that turn implied needs into explicit needs.

Value

  • "If you could see that number by transaction, what would you do differently on Monday?"
  • "What would 100 basis points be worth to the board conversation?"
  • "If this were fixed by the end of the second quarter, what would that make possible?"

Definition of success

  • "How would you know this had worked? What would you look at?"
  • "What would you need to see at the end of a first phase to fund a second?"
  • "What would make this a bad outcome even if the number moved?"

Constraints on the solution

  • "What would a solution have to protect: which customers, which people, which relationships?"
  • "Who has to be able to defend the answer, and what would they need in their hands to do it?"
  • "What would you not want us to touch?"

Ownership after the engagement

  • "Who would run this once we are gone, and what would they need?"
  • "What has stopped previous answers from sticking?"

Internal selling

  • "When you take this to the board, what is the one chart you want to show them?"
  • "Who will argue against it, and what will they say?"

5. Questions for the advance

Ask for a specific next action before the meeting ends. Decide which one you want before the meeting begins.

  • "Could you release the transaction extract under NDA by Tuesday so that we can test this before we write anything?"
  • "Would you set up thirty minutes with [the sceptic] this week? If they do not believe this, it will not happen."
  • "Can we put the scoping session with [the CEO] on the calendar for the week of [date]?"
  • "If we bring a one-page scope and a price range to that meeting, would you be in a position to say yes or no?"
  • "What would you need from us before then to be able to decide?"

If the client offers a continuation ("send us something and we will get back to you"), convert it: "Happy to. What date should I hold for us to walk through it together?"

6. Re-scoping questions for a live engagement

Use when a scope request arrives or an assumption fails.

  • "What has changed since we scoped this, and is the original objective still the right one?"
  • "If we add this, what would you be willing to drop or defer to keep the date?"
  • "Is this a phase-three item, or does it have to be in the pilot?"
  • "Who needs to approve the extra cost, and when do they next meet?"
  • "If we absorbed this without a change order, what would you expect us to absorb next?" (Ask this one of yourself, not the client.)

7. Sequencing patterns

First meeting with an economic buyer (45 to 60 minutes): two or three Situation questions to show preparation; three Problem questions; two Implication questions with arithmetic; two Need-payoff questions; one request for an advance. Leave ten minutes to say what you have seen elsewhere (the Challenger warmer) and to test the reframe hypothesis lightly: "One thing we often find in situations like this is X. Does that ring true here?"

Interview with a sceptical operator: lead with Problem questions about their world, not the sponsor's. Ask Implication questions about the consequences for their people and customers. Ask Need-payoff questions about what they would need to defend a change. Sceptics become mobilizers when the answer protects what they care about.

Scoping meeting with the CEO: open with the reframe and its evidence (Challenger steps one to four), then Need-payoff questions only: what success looks like, what to protect, who runs it afterwards. End with the proposal date and the names who will be in the room.