Reference · Firm lenses

Firm Lenses — McKinsey / Bain / BCG idioms

Load when **Firm idioms**.

Part of the Strategy Toolkit skill · loaded on demand from SKILL.md

The 21 moves are written in common consulting vocabulary. This glossary lets you re-flavor any move in a house idiom — useful when matching a client's expected vocabulary, or when a particular framework sharpens a particular move. The method of a move rarely changes; the frameworks and language layered onto it do. Pick the lens, then apply the named frameworks where the move's method calls for an environment read, a positioning cut, a value anchor, a decision-rights call, or a change model.

Each framework sits under the firm that originated it. Frameworks that no house owns are in the shared vocabulary section at the end; use them under any lens and cite the originator if a client asks.


McKinsey lens — structure and rigor

The McKinsey idiom emphasizes airtight logical structure and hypothesis-driven problem solving. Apply it when the audience values defensibility and the issue is analytically complex.

  • MECE issue trees — decompose every question into mutually exclusive, collectively exhaustive branches (the backbone of the 8-stage workflow's "map the logic"). Use in: situation-assessment, growth-barriers, strategic-options.
  • Pyramid Principle (Minto) — governing thought on top, MECE supporting arguments below, evidence beneath; answer-first. Use in: narrative-builder, decision-memo, and packaging any deliverable.
  • SCQA — Situation, Complication, Question, Answer as the opening frame. Use across framing, narrative, and any board document.
  • Hypothesis-driven problem solving — write the hypothesis before the analysis; spend effort only on branches that can change the answer (the 80/20 rule itself is Pareto's; the hypothesis-first discipline is the house method). The whole workflow.
  • Three Horizons (Baghai, Coley and White, The Alchemy of Growth, 1999) — defend and extend the core (H1), build emerging businesses (H2), create viable options (H3). Use in: strategic-options, transformation-roadmap.

Where it's strongest: diagnosis and the analytical spine.


Bain lens — value and results

The Bain idiom anchors everything to value creation and to actually delivering it. Apply it when the engagement is about results, ownership, and closing a performance gap.

  • Gap to full potential — the value frame: the distance between today's performance and what the business could achieve with its binding constraints relieved (not a forecast or stretch target). Anchor every diagnosis, case, and KPI to it. Use in: situation-assessment, growth-barriers, business-case-builder, kpi-architect, value-realization.
  • Founder's Mentality (Zook and Allen, 2016) — insurgent vs incumbent; the three crises (loss of insurgent mission, of frontline obsession, of owner mindset). Predicts how a business — or a rival — behaves. Use in: situation-assessment, competitive-intel, operating-model-design.
  • Net Promoter System / loyalty economics (Reichheld, 2003) — promoters vs detractors and the retention/repeat/referral economics they drive; a strong margin on a weak NPS warns the value base is eroding. Use in: situation-assessment, customer-segmentation, growth-barriers, kpi-architect.
  • Elements of Value (Almquist, Senior and Bloch, HBR September 2016) — functional / emotional / life-changing / social-impact elements that drive choice and willingness to pay. Use in: customer-segmentation, pricing-strategy.
  • Profit from the Core — Engine 1 / Engine 2 (Zook and Allen, 2001 onward) — strengthen the defended core; expand into earnable adjacencies; build the next core. The structure for option generation and portfolio choice. Use in: strategic-options, market-mapping, profit-pool-analysis, portfolio-review.
  • RAPID decision roles (Rogers and Blenko, HBR January 2006) — Recommend, Agree, Input, Decide (one accountable D), Perform. Owning move: stakeholder-alignment. Referenced by: operating-model-design, decision-memo, assumption-audit, risk-mitigation.
  • Microbattles (Zook and Allen) — a small set of specific, winnable fights with owners and near-term results, instead of a vague program. Use in: initiative-prioritizer, transformation-roadmap.
  • Results Delivery Office — Bain's transformation office: one place that tracks each workstream's benefit to the bottom line, has Finance verify it, and holds owners to milestones. Use in: transformation-roadmap, value-realization. (Stage gates and the value ledger it runs are shared vocabulary, below.)

Where it's strongest: execution and value capture — the "make it actually happen and prove it" half.


BCG lens — advantage and adaptation

The BCG idiom emphasizes the economics of advantage and matching strategy to the environment. Apply it when the question is about competitive economics, portfolio shape, or how to compete under a particular kind of uncertainty.

  • Strategy Palette (Reeves, Haanaes and Sinha, 2015) — classify the environment before choosing an approach: classical (predictable, build position), adaptive (unpredictable, experiment fast), visionary (shape a new market you can predict), shaping (orchestrate an ecosystem), renewal (restore viability under pressure). The environment read that gates option generation. Use in: strategic-options, situation-assessment, assumption-audit.
  • Growth-Share Matrix (Henderson, 1970) — star / cash cow / question mark / dog; the signature portfolio lens and its cash-flow logic (cows fund stars and selected question marks; divest dogs). Use in: portfolio-review.
  • Experience curve (Henderson, 1968) — unit cost falls predictably with cumulative volume, so scale and share drive cost position. Underpins competitive and pricing economics. Use in: competitive-intel, pricing-strategy, growth-barriers (cost-position constraint), profit-pool-analysis.
  • Advantage Matrix (Lochridge, 1981) — classify a business by the number of ways to gain advantage × the size of advantage (fragmented / specialized / stalemate / volume). Use in: competitive-intel.
  • TSR decomposition — total shareholder return split into profit growth, multiple change, and cash returns; the value-creation yardstick of BCG's Value Creators reports. Use in: business-case-builder, kpi-architect, portfolio-review, value-realization, narrative-builder (the value-creation so-what).
  • De-averaging — break blended figures apart to find where the real economics live (the BCG name for the de-blending discipline). Use across diagnosis.
  • Smart Simplicity (Morieux, 2011) — design the organization around the cooperation that actually produces value, not boxes and rules (six smart rules). Use in: operating-model-design.
  • DICE (Sirkin, Keenan and Jackson, "The Hard Side of Change Management", HBR October 2005) — Duration, Integrity, Commitment, Effort; execution-risk scoring. Owning move: initiative-prioritizer. Referenced by: transformation-roadmap, stakeholder-alignment (commitment risk).
  • Head, Heart and Hands (Hemerling, Kilmann and Matthews, BCG, November 2018) — the change model: Head (a clear vision and a focused set of actions), Heart (purpose, culture, leadership; the reason people commit), Hands (ways of working, skills, tools). The phrase predates BCG in education; the transformation framework is theirs. Use in: transformation-roadmap, stakeholder-alignment.

Where it's strongest: competitive economics, portfolio shape, and reading the kind of uncertainty you face.


Shared vocabulary — frameworks no house owns

  • Porter's Five Forces (Michael Porter, HBR 1979) — rivalry, entry barriers, supplier/buyer power, substitution — the structural profit-pressure backdrop. Use in: competitive-intel, market-mapping, situation-assessment.
  • Theory of Constraints (Eliyahu Goldratt, The Goal, 1984) — find the single binding constraint that caps the system; relieving anything else is wasted motion. Use in: growth-barriers (the five-whys to the binding constraint), operating-model-design.
  • Pre-mortem (Gary Klein, "Performing a Project Premortem", HBR September 2007) — assume the plan has already failed and work back to the causes. Owning move: risk-mitigation. Referenced by: assumption-audit, stakeholder-alignment.
  • Stage gates (Robert Cooper's Stage-Gate process, late 1980s) — phases that release funding only when the prior phase has proven its result. Owning move: value-realization. Referenced by: assumption-audit, risk-mitigation, transformation-roadmap.
  • Value ledger — benefits-tracking vocabulary rather than a house framework: every benefit with size, owner, baseline and assumption, reconciled to the case. Use in: value-realization.
  • Value migration (Adrian Slywotzky, Value Migration, 1996, written at Mercer Management Consulting) — profit moving from one business design to another as customer priorities shift; map the vector, not the snapshot. Use in: profit-pool-analysis, market-mapping.
  • Resilience triad: anticipate / absorb / adapt — the generic resilience vocabulary for classing a response to risk or shock (BCG's own version is anticipation, cushioning, adaptation and shaping). Use in: risk-mitigation, war-gaming.

Choosing a lens

  • Match the client's vocabulary — if they're a McKinsey-trained shop, lead with issue trees and the Pyramid; if Bain, with full potential and RAPID; if BCG, with the Strategy Palette and TSR. The analysis is the same; the framing earns trust.
  • Match the framework to the move — some frameworks are simply the best tool regardless of house: the Growth-Share Matrix for a portfolio review, the Strategy Palette for reading the environment before generating options, NPS/loyalty economics wherever durable value is at stake, RAPID wherever a decision is stalling on ownership.
  • Don't stack three idioms on one slide — pick one lens per deliverable so the language is coherent. When no idiom is called for, use the move as written.